Dog vs. Cat Cost: Which Pet Is Cheaper to Own in the US and Europe?

When people think about getting a pet, one of the first questions is simple: “Should I get a dog or a cat?” Emotionally, both can be wonderful companions. Financially, however, dogs and cats look very different over 10–15 years – especially in the US and Europe, where housing, vet care and pet services can be expensive.

There is no single “right” answer, but understanding the real costs of each animal helps you choose a pet that fits both your heart and your wallet. In this guide, we’ll compare:

• One-time costs of getting a dog vs a cat

• Monthly and yearly expenses you’ll pay for each

• Hidden costs: housing, travel, damage and emergencies

• How lifestyle (apartment vs house, city vs rural) changes the numbers

• When a dog can actually be cheaper – and when a cat clearly wins

1. One-Time Costs: Adoption, Setup and First Vet Visits

Both dogs and cats come with “entry costs” in the first few weeks. These include adoption or purchase, basic supplies and first vet care.

1.1 Adoption vs buying from a breeder

For both species, you usually have two main paths:

• Adoption from a shelter or rescue. Fees are often moderate and may include spay/neuter, vaccines and microchipping.

• Buying from a breeder. Purebred puppies and kittens from responsible breeders usually cost significantly more up front.

In general:

• Purebred dogs from reputable breeders tend to be more expensive than purebred cats.

• Adoption fees for dogs are often slightly higher than for cats, reflecting higher average care costs in shelters.

1.2 Starter supplies: dog vs cat

Both dogs and cats need basic equipment before coming home, but the lists are slightly different.

Dog starter items

• Collar, harness and leash

• Food and water bowls

• Dog bed and/or crate

• Toys (chews, fetch toys, puzzle toys)

• Puppy pads or cleaning products for accidents

• Poop bags and holder

Cat starter items

• Litter box, litter scoop and first bags of litter

• Food and water bowls (or fountain)

• Cat bed or soft blankets

• Scratching post or scratching board

• Toys (feather wand, balls, interactive toys)

• Cat carrier for vet visits

Overall, starter costs for a dog are usually a bit higher because crates, leashes and some training tools add up. Cats need more litter-related items from day one, but these are usually cheaper than a good dog crate and harness set.

1.3 First vet visit, vaccines and surgery

Dogs and cats both need:

• Initial health exam

• Core vaccines

• Spay/neuter (if not already done)

• Microchipping (in many regions)

Vet fees depend on country and city, but as a rough pattern:

• Dogs often cost more: Larger bodies require higher doses of medications and anesthesia.

• Cats are usually cheaper individually, but costs rise if you keep multiple cats.

2. Monthly and Yearly Costs: Food, Litter and Routine Care

Once the initial excitement is over, you face the true financial question: what does this animal cost you every month for the next decade or more?

2.1 Food: dogs usually eat more, especially big ones

Food is one of the biggest recurring costs. The main difference is simple:

• Dogs: Medium and large dogs eat much more than most cats, and higher-quality food raises the bill further.

• Cats: Small bodies = smaller portions. Even premium cat food is often cheaper per month than a similar-quality dog diet (unless you own multiple cats).

A small indoor cat often costs less to feed than a medium or large dog. A tiny toy dog might be similar to, or cheaper than, a cat.

2.2 Litter vs outdoor toilet habits

Here, cats usually cost more:

• Cats: Indoor cats need litter for their entire life. High-quality clumping litter, especially in small US and European apartments, can be a significant monthly expense.

• Dogs: Most dogs go outdoors. You buy poop bags, but there is no constant litter cost.

So while dogs often eat more food, cats burn money in the litter tray every month.

2.3 Routine vet care and preventives

Both species need:

• Annual or semi-annual health exams

• Vaccine boosters as recommended

• Flea, tick and worm prevention (especially if going outdoors)

In many cases:

• Dogs: Preventive medicines are dosed by weight, so large dogs cost more. Regular nail trims, ear cleanings and dental checks may be needed more frequently.

• Cats: Usually cheaper per visit, but outdoor cats may need more parasite control and treatment for fights or injuries.

2.4 Insurance and long-term health risks

Pet insurance premiums reflect risk:

• Policies for dogs usually cost more than for cats.

• Large and certain purebred dogs can be particularly expensive to insure.

• Cats often have lower premiums, especially indoor cats with fewer accident risks.

Over 10–15 years, pet insurance can make total dog ownership more expensive, even as it protects you from huge surprise bills.

3. Hidden Costs: Housing, Travel and Damage

The biggest differences between dogs and cats often show up in the “invisible” parts of your budget – your home, your schedule and your holidays.

3.1 Housing: dogs usually restrict your options more

• Dogs: Many landlords in the US and Europe are stricter about dogs, especially large or “restricted” breeds. You may face higher deposits, monthly pet rent or fewer available apartments.

• Cats: Some buildings are more relaxed about cats, especially indoor-only cats. You may still pay pet deposits, but there are often more pet-friendly options.

If you live in a tight rental market, the extra housing cost of a dog can be larger than any difference in food or vet bills.

3.2 Travel and holidays

When you travel:

• Dogs: Boarding kennels, dog hotels or dog sitters can be expensive. Taking dogs on flights or trains often requires additional fees and paperwork.

• Cats: Many cats do better staying at home with a pet sitter visiting once or twice a day. Boarding catteries are usually quieter and sometimes cheaper than dog facilities.

For frequent travelers, a cat can be noticeably cheaper and easier to manage.

3.3 Damage to your home and belongings

Both species can cause damage, but in slightly different ways:

• Dogs: Chewed furniture, shoes, doors and fences. Scratches from running and playing. Mud tracked onto carpets.

• Cats: Scratched sofas, chairs and curtains. Cat hair on soft surfaces. Occasional accidents outside the litter box.

Which is “worse” depends on the individual animal and your home. A bored large dog can destroy more value in a single afternoon than most cats will in a year. On the other hand, some cats relentlessly scratch expensive furniture unless you provide and train them to use good scratching posts.

4. Time Cost vs Money Cost: Dogs Need More Daily Work

The “price” of a pet is not only about money – it’s also about time.

4.1 Dogs: daily walks, training and attention

Most dogs need:

• Multiple walks every day, even in bad weather

• Training for basic manners and leash skills

• More direct interaction and play to stay calm and happy

If you cannot provide this yourself, you may pay for:

• Dog walkers

• Doggy daycare

• Training classes or private sessions

4.2 Cats: lower daily time cost, but still need care

Most cats:

• Use a litter box, so no outdoor walks are required

• Are happy with shorter, more flexible play sessions

• Can be left alone for part of the day more easily than most dogs

They still need:

• Daily feeding and fresh water

• Litter box cleaning

• Play and enrichment to prevent boredom and stress

In purely practical terms, cats usually have a lower “time cost” than dogs, which also reduces the need for paid services like dog walkers.

5. Health and Lifespan: How Long You’ll Be Paying

Dogs and cats age differently, and that affects long-term costs.

5.1 Average lifespan

• Dogs: Lifespan varies by size and breed. Many dogs live 10–13 years, but giant breeds may live fewer years and small breeds can live longer.

• Cats: Indoor cats commonly live 14–18 years or more, so costs are spread over a longer period.

5.2 Senior pet costs

Senior years are often more expensive for both species due to:

• Chronic diseases (arthritis, kidney disease, heart problems, etc.)

• More frequent vet visits

• Medications and special diets

A long-lived cat may accumulate more senior-year costs simply because they live into older age. Large dogs may have a shorter senior phase but more expensive orthopedic issues.

6. When a Dog Might Be Cheaper – and When a Cat Clearly Wins

In some situations, a dog can actually be relatively economical; in others, a cat is clearly the budget-friendly choice.

6.1 When a dog can be the cheaper option

A dog may be relatively inexpensive to own if:

• You choose a small or medium mixed-breed dog with fewer known genetic risks.

• You live in a place with pet-friendly housing at no extra cost.

• You work from home or have flexible hours, so you don’t pay for walkers or daycare.

• You are active and use daily walks as exercise, saving money on other hobbies.

• You focus on preventive care and good training, reducing damage and emergencies.

6.2 When a cat is usually the cheaper option

A cat is typically less expensive when:

• You rent in a city where dogs trigger high pet deposits or strict rules.

• You travel frequently and prefer a pet sitter to live-in care.

• You want a companion but have limited time for training and daily exercise.

• You choose an indoor mixed-breed cat with relatively low vet risk.

For many busy apartment dwellers in the US and Europe, a cat gives a lot of emotional value with lower ongoing cost and time demands.

7. How to Decide: Cost + Lifestyle + Personality

Instead of asking “Is a dog or cat cheaper?”, a better question is:

“Which animal fits my budget, my home and my daily routine – not just this year, but for the next 10–15 years?”

7.1 Questions to ask yourself

• How many hours am I away from home on a typical day?

• Do I enjoy going outside multiple times a day, even in bad weather?

• How often do I travel, and how would I arrange pet care?

• What is my realistic monthly budget for food, litter, vet care and emergencies?

• Am I more comfortable planning daily walks and training, or short bursts of indoor play?

7.2 The emotional side still matters

Money is important, but so is personality. Some people simply feel happier with dogs; others are true “cat people”. The key is to:

• Understand the real costs of your preference

• Adjust your budget and lifestyle honestly

• Choose an individual dog or cat whose energy level and temperament match your life

8. Final Thoughts: The Cheapest Pet Is the One You Can Truly Support

Over a full lifetime, most dogs cost more money and time than most cats, especially in urban areas of the US and Europe. But a small, well-chosen dog in a pet-friendly home can still be affordable. A long-lived cat, meanwhile, can become a relatively low-cost, high-reward companion if you plan for food, litter, vet care and emergencies.

The “cheapest” pet is not the one with the lowest monthly bill. It is the one you can:

• Feed appropriately

• Provide with necessary medical care

• Keep safe, stimulated and loved

• Support financially in both normal months and stressful emergencies

If you choose wisely, budget realistically and think long term, both dogs and cats can be priceless additions to your life – without becoming a constant financial surprise.

animal tags: dog vs cat cost pet cost comparison cost of owning a dog cost of owning a cat pet budget pet expenses pet owners in the US pet owners in Europe choosing a pet dog or cat which is cheaper

We created this article in conjunction with AI technology, then made sure it was fact-checked and edited by a Animals Top editor.